Advertising is bad (rant)

How can you say something like that? Ads keep websites free to use and we need ads to get informed about things!”

Technically somewhat true. Advertising can (or could) be useful to inform people about your business or your (new) products. The problem is: They have gone too far. Ads are everywhere. And they are – for the most – not factual information but often misleading and made by professionals just to grab attention.¹ There is only one direction: Louder, more dazzling, bigger, more aggressive!

WILL YOU PAY ATTENTION TO ME?!?! I AM AN IMPORTANT, FANCY AD!!!

Because advertising has become really annoying I started avoiding any form of ads.
Watching classic TV? Nah. Go away. Haven’t seen or heard any commercials for years since I stopped watching TV more than a decade ago.
Listening to the radio? Only in the car for two minutes to hear if there is a traffic jam where I want to drive.
Newspapers and magazines? I don’t buy them for the most. In the past I bought MAD (guess what: It was expensive and had no ads) and I buy Desinfec’t (C’T special once a year with license for four anti-virus engines on a live Ubuntu by Heise Verlag). That one is about €10 and the very small magazine has almost no ads.
Even waiting for the bus can become a major headache. Each bus stop in the city has some huge posters.
=========

Now to the most problematic topic: Online advertising. I hate it with passion. It is more than static images or video or audio. It is active. It has tracking. Tries to target people. (Google) Analytics. Statistics. Argh! How should I be convinced to buy anything – from a stalker? Malvertising anyone? Just leave me alone!
This is my computer. My CPU. My battery and my electricity bill. Stop wasting my compute power with aggressive animation. Stop wasting bandwidth with videos. Stop stalking. Stop fingerprinting. Stop being obtrusive. Just stop being an a..hole! I will not look at your stuff just because you get even more importunate.

Again: They have gone too far, too aggressive, too invasive, much of a pain. So I chose to block them all. Collective punishment. It will wrongly hurt those who were/are moderate with their campaigns. Maybe I’ll miss something which would indeed be of interest for me. Send your thanks to those who are obtrusive. Whenever I think about this topic, I hear the song from this one ingenious Simpson Halloween episode (with the giant ad characters wrecking the town) in my head. Ads are indeed monsters and they will lose their power when ignored.

Turn on Javascript and turn off your adblocker to use this website.” How about “NO!”? I’ll just leave. I will rather pay with money for an online service than with my personal data/privacy and my time and my nerves! The Pi-hole will stay. So will uMatrix and uBlock Origin.



===========
I’ll stop here and rather let this be a rant than providing loads of arguments for my point of view that nobody will read anyway.

View attachment 262661
View attachment 262662
View attachment 262766
_________________
¹ What those professionals often seem to forget is, that grabbing attention is only one part of the way to success. If you grabbed my attention with aggressive colors and some stupid slogan that is burned into the brain after seeing or hearing it once, I can tell you one thing: I will never be your customer!
  • Like
Reactions: 11 people

Comments

Edward Bernays really led us down this doomed rabbit hole.

Ads, I think, are universally hated. They get in the way at best, and redirect and stalk you at worst.

But people have to eat. So those that need money have moved to sponsorship deals. Of which are yet another beast that gets in the way of our entertainment. But it's a necessary evil. For websites, not many are going to pay to join a site exclusively for its content (how many people pay the 15/mo for Hulu, but refuse to pay for Bloomberg?)

What can you do? Adblock is prevalent and understandable in its dislike. So where does that leave the small fries that can't survive without it? Patreon or sponsors. Those are the future. And ads on top, cuz why not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
If I ran the world, people would be absolutely forced to watch ads and then fill out forms to prove they absorbed the information
 
@Flofflewoffle It is indeed. But the extension is discontinued. As long as it is still working and compatible… all good. Else I'll go back to NoScript.

@Chary "But it's a necessary evil." → This opinion has sadly become more or less consensus. I disagree with that. There should be easy to use alternatives. I'm sick of being treated like some kind of parasite when using adblock in self-defense. Patreon, while not perfect, is a good starting point. I feel better using GBAtemp with the small monthly payment – but the blocking addons will stay active (sometimes uBlock is needed for certain avatars or signatures).

@yuyuyup Is this supposed to be funny?

@raging_chaos Is this also supposed to be funny? It is not a disguised ad for the blockers I use. There are a lot of alternatives like Adblock Plus and NoScript as browser addons and the host file on your computer instead of Pi-Hole.

@notrea11y Will watch the video later. But why: “Never leave the house without uBlock”?
 
"Never leave the house" in the aspect of 'mobile devices' and meant in a metaphorical sense at best, I suppose.
(Reason why my iPad is collecting dust, as it lacks proper adblocking).

Sometimes my jokes are even too much for me I guess, haha.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Oh, yes. I was moreso saying that ads seem to be so hated and as a result, alternatives are beginning to crop up, and seem more user friendly. (but those come with struggles of their own) not that we as the consumer should take ads laying down. Because alternatives will keep happening no matter what.

I browsed gbatemp for years without adblock, and I know the admins do their best to hunt down and kill every malicious ad on this website. And I appreciate that effort. But at this point, if I didn't have patreon status, I 100% would be using an adblock (and I say that as someone who loves this site so much)

I set up a pi-hole last week and it's my new favorite thing, honestly. I had no idea it existed and idk how I'd manage without one, now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
@raging_chaos Is this also supposed to be funny? It is not a disguised ad for the blockers I use. There are a lot of alternatives like Adblock Plus and NoScript as browser addons and the host file on your computer instead of Pi-Hole.

Woosh
 
Turn on Javascript and turn off your adblocker to use this website.” How about “NO!”? I’ll just leave. I will rather pay with money for an online service than with my personal data/privacy and my time and my nerves! The Pi-hole will stay. So will uMatrix and uBlock Origin.

Bravo and yes,of course.:yay:


Oh dear,sooo many "Free Download Sites" refuses now to work correctly...
Too bad...:rofl2:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Chary I was wondering after that other thread if you were questioning my love of the site after I said who pays to remove ads. But you pretty much cleared that up in your above post cause you said you would be using adblock if you never had a patreon lol.

I love this site but simply don't have the funds to make a monthly donation to it.

As regards adverts I hate them especially on TV. I record absolutely everything simply to be able to fast forward past adverts. I can't remember the last time I watched something at the actual time it was broadcast.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
It's amazing how huge and resource-hungry ads have become, to the point where older or slower devices can't even load the site... but when you use adblocker the site loads fine. There is absolutely no need for ads to take up that much RAM or CPU, that's bullshit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
@Veho: this is why I use NoScript, because not only have ads become more resource hungry, but websites in general.
I can barely find a website which isn't a "single-page" shitty bloated crap which is intentionally made in a way to force enable Javascript.

Oh, and don't let me get started on websites which BLOCK THE BROWSER SERVER-SIDE because it doesn't contain the technologies required to serve them ads properly. I once got a "Bad Request" error code because my browser lacks some newly introduced crap which is required by their ad framework. This is why I also have an user-agent switcher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
I do have to chime in to mention
https://sponsor.ajay.app/

Is basically a database of timecodes for "this video sponsored by [insert VPN/mobile phone company/giz coins or get lost mobile game/headphones/skincare/food delivery/podcast/audio/monthly box of junk that could not be sold otherwise/...]" and it skips them all (if "this video sponsored by", followed by long advert ? minutes in and "check out our sponsor" then all three) for you.

Combined with your chosen ad blocking options it makes the internet quite pleasant.
Noscript... surprisingly it is somewhat better as a general end user experience than it was 10 years ago where it was a bit of a chore and I would never install it for a general client where every client gets adblock unless specifically not requested. Some reckon that might be sites shifting to prerendered. That said I had a few weeks with it in recent months, was not inclined to keep it active though and the only reason it is still installed is for my fiddling purposes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Ironically, GBATemp used to be the worst offender in terms of online ads until I finally discovered the "Disable affiliate videos" option in the user settings. Who the heck thinks it is supposed to be a good idea to enable autoplaying videos by default!? I couldn't even figure out how to consistently block them manually.

I tried to tolerate online ads in general, but I gave up after I saw "One trick of a flat belly" for the jillionth time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
I cant live without my blockers at this point, pihole is a life saver and so is noscript(i also have ublock for those few ads my pihole doesn't cover)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Thank you all for the comments.

@raging_chaos
Seriously "Woosh"? Shall I look it up on urbandictionary.com? Better not. Sounds like the words shown in comic style in the old Batman series with Adam West – when Batman and Robin fight the villains.
Okay: "Woosh, bang, boom, splatch" to you as well. Whatever it means.

@alexander1970 Free download sites? For Windows freeware? Thank goodness I use Linux.

@AmandaRose Guess what made me write this blog entry. This.

@Veho and @Sono Resource-hungry and bloated are good keywords. There is no reason why anything does have to be this bloated on the web. Making devices just a few years old struggle when opening a website – with or without ads – is BS.

@FAST6191 Thank you! I didn’t know about this. This “Special deal for you on Blabla-VPN!” and “Don’t forget to hit that like button and subscribe!” is a major annoyance.

@Kwyjor It can be a good idea to browse settings once in a while. I think the thing with the affiliate videos was even mentioned.

@Scott_pilgrim Pi-hole is cool. Using it for years. Protects even virtual machines, live-Linux and the like where no complete browser profile exists.
===========

It is very hard to run a site without ads at the moment; I fully understand this. It wouldn't be a problem if it were some unobtrusive, non-tracking static banners without tons of active code. The way online advertising currently is: No.
I would not have touched this topic if there wasn't the possibility to use Patreon for payment. Although I generally have my problems with signing up here and there and giving away credit card information, I said to myself last year: "Only moaning about ads and doing nothing yourself is not convincing and will not help." So I forced myself and never regretted. Anyone who can afford it and regularly uses the site should at least consider it in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
"Seriously "Woosh"? Shall I look it up on urbandictionary.com? Better not. Sounds like the words shown in comic style in the old Batman series with Adam West – when Batman and Robin fight the villains."
It's supposed to represent the sound of a joke going over someone's head
 
"@FAST6191 Thank you! I didn’t know about this. This “Special deal for you on Blabla-VPN!” and “Don’t forget to hit that like button and subscribe!” is a major annoyance."

The like and subscribe thing would probably be a separate application (though I suppose a fork or secondary database would work there). Personally I have a remote control or arrow keys which skip a few seconds and that sorts it.
 
@FAST6191 you can configure to block and submit different kinds of annoyances in the extension's settings.
 

Blog entry information

Author
KleinesSinchen
Views
763
Comments
58
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

More entries from KleinesSinchen

General chit-chat
Help Users
    Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty: @K3Nv2, so smart it doesnt even exist