Something To Talk About no. 1: Gender-flipping

Warning: Something To Talk About is mostly, if not entirely subjective. Potentially controversial opinions may be found. Thank you for your understanding.

Gender flipping, in my eyes, is a marketing practice to appease the Internet. But let's be honest, that's some lazy crap right there.

Rather than develop a new character, why flop someone else's? From what I've seen, it's laziness and pandering.

Laziness:
Swapping a character's gender simply takes less time than creating a new one. You already have a name, backstory, and rough view of the appearance, that you can draw up a character model and you're pretty much finished. It's requires less time, less creativity, and keeps production fast. However, a large amount of people may find it distasteful. Certain characters being gender-swapped ruins the original feel of the story, especially if it's a nostalgic feel. Imagine if a game you played forever ago gender-swapped the protagonist in a remake, if a movie swapped the main love interest from the book you read, this changes a lot of the original feel of the story you remember.

Pandering:
The world is focusing on equality right now. Thus, businesses think "this story seems more "male-oriented", please the people with a gender-swapped character." They can endear themselves to a larger audience by making the game seem more "equal."


However, in my opinion there are some good gender swaps. This is because they reformed the story around the character, not reformed the character around the story. This added an effective twist that required some effort, and actually rocked.

In television:
Erica Goldberg was an impressive way of Adam switching his brother Eric over to Erica in The Goldbergs. It added some more wacky scenarios to the story that I typically would not have expected. Since it was more or less based on a true story, it definitely changed some things around.

In video games:
FeMC in Persona 3 Portable added an entirely different storyline based around a female protagonist rather than a male one. Sadly, this has never been introduced in another mainstream Persona game, making it a kind of wasted feature. With ATLUS adding the female protagonist, the story changed so much it actually is set in another universe.


So, basically, most of the time they suck, but if done right, it changes a lot around.

This has been an article of Something To Talk About. If you would like something to be talked about, leave me a DM and I'll look through it.
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people

Comments

Flipping something is part of the creative process. Not very deep, but important one.
Like there is soccer. Bunch of men running on grass. What if we'll change grass to water? Cool we have water polo now.
This technique might seem to be a bit lazy, but it still got a chance to work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
It's a tool, and it's all about how it is used, though it is often used to pull up a cheap twist.. It can also be effective, when done right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
(First of all, I'm liking this blog series ... can't wait to see number 2)
I think gender swapping can be awesome if it's actually made into something clever. Like Fionna and Cake Adventure Time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
I don't like how "having a diverse opinion" has to equal a group of various races and sexes and genders, etc., when no two people have the same personality or history regardless of any of that. A group of ten white men has "diverse opinions" since one of those men might be destitute while another is middle-class and another rich - one might be Christian or Buddhist or Jehovah's Witness while another is an atheist. One might have a criminal history, while another has a history of being bullied.

One might be a punster, while another man's serious and rarely displays emotion. One might like books, while another man likes cars and another prefers art. One man might have one sibling, while another man has four. One guy might be from the city, while another's a country bumpkin. Et cetera.

Dismissing this diversity in favour of having a variety of races and genders can come off as pandering and ignorance, to me - ignoring one form of diversity to promote another form of diversity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Gender-Flipping...is this like a house-flippers situation where someone comes in and turns your body into an open concept?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person

Blog entry information

Author
WG481
Views
386
Comments
26
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

More entries from WG481

General chit-chat
Help Users
    Xdqwerty @ Xdqwerty: ill have no wifi for a bit so see ya later