GBAtemp Game of the Year 2017 Voting: PlayStation
From what it looks like the kingdom hearts game you are mentioning contained two remasters and a remake of the 3ds kingdom hearts game, whereas the entirety of the n. Sane trilogy is a remake. As for wind waker, I haven't found any proof pointing to whether it was a remake or a remaster. Although the developer said that it had just enough changes to call it a remake, it was developed in six months (which seems like a short development time to rebuild a game from the ground up imo) and I haven't found any documentation on how the game was developed (meaning, there's no proof that the code for the Wii u version did or didn't share similar code to the GameCube version). Also, as stated earlier in this thread by Tom:By your definition, Kingdom Hearts REMAKE and Wind Waker REMAKE are NEW games too then? So why weren't they ever nominated for any kind of subjective award? What about final fantasy 12? That's a remake too
From what it looks like the kingdom hearts game you are mentioning contained two remasters and a remake of the 3ds kingdom hearts game, whereas the entirety of the n. Sane trilogy is a remake. As for wind waker, I haven't found any proof pointing to whether it was a remake or a remaster. Although the developer said that it had just enough changes to call it a remake, it was developed in six months (which seems like a short development time to rebuild a game from the ground up imo) and I haven't found any documentation on how the game was developed (meaning, there's no proof that the code for the Wii u version did or didn't share similar code to the GameCube version). Also, as stated earlier in this thread by Tom:
"Show me Crash Bandicoot N.Sane Trilogy on the PS1 please. Y'know, that great collection of all three Crash games, totally released on the PS1. Oh right, you can't, you're just being a semantic ass."
Looks like I had misinformation on the kingdom hearts 2.8, as it was just a remake of dream drop resistance that added new stuff (I thought it was a collection of some of the older PlayStation titles that were remastered plus the 3ds game that was remade on top). As for wind waker, a source please? Because I've looked high and low and haven't found anything that says whether it was in fact a complete remake or reused code from the original GameCube version except the comment from the developer I mentioned earlier.Your Nsane. you say KH isn't a remake yet it is exactly what you described in crash collection. Birth by sleep PSP, dream drop 3ds, show me where those games are on a system together smdh... And we all know the assets for kingdom hearts got lost after the ps2 that they had to rebuild the whole thing from scratch, same as wind waker. They even changed the controls for kingdom hearts camera by switching it to the rstick instead of RL.
It doesn't make it a 'new' game. I played crashed 1+2+3 on the psx and its the same exact damn game, the levels are the same exact levels its not a 2017 game no matter how hard you really like this game and dream it to be on any sort of goty besides this list here at gbatemp.
Looks like I had misinformation on the kingdom hearts 2.8, as it was just a remake of dream drop resistance that added new stuff (I thought it was a collection of some of the older PlayStation titles that were remastered plus the 3ds game that was remade on top). As for wind waker, a source please? Because I've looked high and low and haven't found anything that says whether it was in fact a complete remake or reused code from the original GameCube version except the comment from the developer I mentioned earlier.
--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------
And also, whether you like it or not, crash nsane trilogy technically is a "new game". Last I checked it wasn't coded in the 90s, and also last I checked there wasn't a game that contained all of the original three crash games on the ps1. As to whether a new game should be disqualified as a new game because it features some of the same levels is a whole other argument for another day.
Actually, I'm not new to crash bandicoot. Crash was a huge part of my childhood (however I didn't grow up with the original trilogy, I grew up with wrath of cortex, tag team racing, and the gba games). I didn't get to play the original trilogy until a couple of years ago with the Vita.yea i cant find the source on windwaker but i think i heard it a long time ago, but your probably new to crash bandicoot, it was great series.
i always thought it was stupid p5 wasnt a simultaneous release solely because of potential goty stuff like this thread. p5 was going head to head with ffxv and both of them messed up their releases (ffxv released AFTER black friday and persona delaying the usa release til 2017 because final fantasy is more popular in the usa/eu and didnt want to be overshadowed (assuming)) but persona IS a 2016 game
Actually, I'm not new to crash bandicoot. Crash was a huge part of my childhood (however I didn't grow up with the original trilogy, I grew up with wrath of cortex, tag team racing, and the gba games). I didn't get to play the original trilogy until a couple of years ago with the Vita.
As for persona, it's always seemed fairly popular to me at least here in the west. Definitely not as popular as final fantasy though. It probably didn't release in 2016 here in the west not because of awards, but because localizing such a big game takes a looong time.
The KH are just Remasters not remakes. The only remakes that exist are Re: Chain of Memories and Re:Coded. DDD was a port to the PS4Your Nsane. you say KH isn't a remake yet it is exactly what you described in crash collection. Birth by sleep PSP, dream drop 3ds, show me where those games are on a system together smdh... And we all know the assets for kingdom hearts got lost after the ps2 that they had to rebuild the whole thing from scratch, same as wind waker. They even changed the controls for kingdom hearts camera by switching it to the rstick instead of RL.
It doesn't make it a 'new' game. I played crashed 1+2+3 on the psx and its the same exact damn game, the levels are the same exact levels its not a 2017 game no matter how hard you really like this game and dream it to be on any sort of goty besides this list here at gbatemp.
From what I read the ddd port was technically a remake. The PS4 version had a complete overhaul because the 3ds version originally used two screens.The KH are just Remasters not remakes. The only remakes that exist are Re: Chain of Memories and Re:Coded. DDD was a port to the PS4
Tomb Raider 2013 would be considered a reboot, not a remake.A remake is Tomb Raider 2013 a fresh start and totally new game, they didnt just rebuild the original and add an extra tit because that doesn't make it a new game