Also it feels great for the Jews that they know they have their own country if it wasn't for Israel they wouldn't have their own country.
Etalon said:Hardcore Antisemitism was not invented by the Nazis.
I know that. But what you said was that "Zionist ideology" was a term coined by the Nazi's. If it was a term coined by the Nazi's then it would not have existed before either the writing of Mein Kampf nor the creation of NSDAP. And for what it's worth the Nazi's usually referred to them simply as "The Jewry" or "The Jewish problem".
So now you think we have to give Arizona, Texas and all those other states back to Mexico because we stole their land?QUOTE said:This is the foundation of "Zionist ideology" - and it's a well known fake
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protocols..._Elders_of_Zion
That's not where I got my information. I got my information from reading the history of the foundation of the state of Israel, writings from famous Zionists and Anti-Zionists, pro and anti-Israel propaganda, and people like Chomsky, Finklestein and others. I've also read stuff from people like Dershowitz.
QUOTE said:This is the real foundation of Israel:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodor_Herzl
And Herzl wanted peace and harmony between all people that live in Israel. He didn't even care about his own religion. Nobody does...
He did indeed. He was a supporter of a form of National Socialism (yes, National Socialism was around long before the Nazi's took it and twisted it into their hate filled Utra-nationalist ideology). Unfortunately Zionism in it's original form was hijacked by Ultra-nationalists. If you follow Zionism from the early 1900's (basically from when they were offered land, in Uganda I believe it was) to when Gurion took over you can see the changes that took place. With the internet it's also become alot easier to do this.
BlueStar said:Would feel great for the Palestinians to have their own country as well I imagine. Would feel great if I had my own country as well, can I have yours?
I wonder how supportive they'd be if say the UN told the USA that they had to give one of the States back to the Native Americans so the could rebuild their homeland?
QUOTE(Jakob95 @ Feb 4 2011, 03:38 PM)
The Living Shadow said:I've been sitting back and watching this for a while, In part because I was busy and couldn't participate and I also wanted to see where this would go. People seem to forget their history all to quick. and I hope to remind people of the influence it can have on a society. Now, what exactly do I mean by that? well, lets start with the muslim brotherhood.. did you know of there founding influences? I do, they where radicalized by NAZI Germany! Do you not believe me, then have a read. You would be surprised! but that's not all, there are reports of iran having informal ties to the muslim brotherhood. Essentially, Iran has it's tentacles spread throughout the region. But what about Iran, how did this all come to be? If penut's Hadn't assisted in the overthrow of the shah of iran, there would be not tentacles to spread! Not to forget, they wouldn't be able to of funded major terrorist groups!
If Iran wasn't radicalized, they wouldn't be able to finance al-Qaeda! If it wasn't for there funding and the ACLU filing of a lawsuit objecting to national security in preference to the right's of 3 people who raised red flags at the airport, 3 out of 3 Billion! Last time I checked, it wasn't 3>3,000,000,000 its 3
princefarzan said:The Living Shadow said:-snip-
You sir, have clearly been watching too much conspiracy theory. Please take your tin foil hat off and go outside once and awhile.
TrolleyDave said:There was a couple of regiments of the SS made up of Muslims although I'm not sure of their connection to the Muslim Brotherhood (if they are linked at all) as I've never looked into it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waffen-SS#1943
Exactly my point. I wouldn't give it back to the Native Americans because its already our land. The same goes for Israel now doesn't it. You just proved me correct.QUOTE said:So if the US was told to give one of the states in the US back to the Native Americans you would be fully supportive of that? After all, it is their homeland.
Jakob95 said:@TrolleyDaveExactly my point. I wouldn't give it back to the Native Americans because its already our land. The same goes for Israel now doesn't it. You just proved me correct.QUOTE said:So if the US was told to give one of the states in the US back to the Native Americans you would be fully supportive of that? After all, it is their homeland.
But you never said anything about the US taking the Native Americans land. You said about the US giving their land back to the Native Americans...TrolleyDave said:Jakob95 said:@TrolleyDaveExactly my point. I wouldn't give it back to the Native Americans because its already our land. The same goes for Israel now doesn't it. You just proved me correct.QUOTE said:So if the US was told to give one of the states in the US back to the Native Americans you would be fully supportive of that? After all, it is their homeland.
No I haven't, in effect you've just proven the Palestinians point. Going by your very own logic the land for Israel should never have been given to the Jewish people because it was already the Palestinians land.
@Living Shadow : Cheers for that info, will have a read of it when I get back from work tomoz.
The Living Shadow said:yea, right.
pitman said:First the Turks start on hating us and now Egypt(only a part of it I believe) wants to destroy us, sigh.
War never changes.
I know what you mean. In all honesty I think it's mostly posturing on the Muslim Brotherhoods part, an attempt to bring Muslims to their side to get in power. They would have to be Osama Bin Laden crazy to start a war with Israel though. They may have allies in nations like Iran, Syria etc. but they're no match really for NATO. A full scale war would be over quite quickly. I'm not overly paranoid about it escalating much further than them attempting to lift the blockade, but there's still a fear for the safety of my mates living in Israel.
QUOTE(Jakob95 @ Feb 5 2011, 03:33 AM) But you never said anything about the US taking the Native Americans land. You said about the US giving their land back to the Native Americans...
So by your logic the Native Americans shouldn't have given their land the United States because they were forced give it to them.TrolleyDave said:pitman said:First the Turks start on hating us and now Egypt(only a part of it I believe) wants to destroy us, sigh.
War never changes.
I know what you mean. In all honesty I think it's mostly posturing on the Muslim Brotherhoods part, an attempt to bring Muslims to their side to get in power. They would have to be Osama Bin Laden crazy to start a war with Israel though. They may have allies in nations like Iran, Syria etc. but they're no match really for NATO. A full scale war would be over quite quickly. I'm not overly paranoid about it escalating much further than them attempting to lift the blockade, but there's still a fear for the safety of my mates living in Israel.
QUOTE(Jakob95 @ Feb 5 2011, 03:33 AM) But you never said anything about the US taking the Native Americans land. You said about the US giving their land back to the Native Americans...
I did indeed. You don't see the flaw in your logic? You're focusing solely on the settlements captured by Israel, what about the land before the modern state of Israel was formed? That was owned by the Palestinians and they were ordered to hand it over to the Jewish people. So if going by your logic that no land should be given back to the Native Americans because it was already yours, then no land should have been given to the Jewish people because it was already the Palestinians. You see? In effect you have proven the Palestinians point.
Jakob95 said:So by your logic the Native Americans shouldn't have given their land the United States because they were forced give it to them.
BlueStar said:The Living Shadow said:yea, right.
Yes, right. You sound like a frothing tin-foil hat wearer, do you actually read what you're typing?
The Muslim Brotherhood is only being spoken of because it's the only opposition party that was partially tolerated by Mubarak, it's not a shoe-in to be the replacement if the US-backed dictatorship crumbles.