Nintendo strikes and blocks YouTube videos for Breath of the Wild's multiplayer mod

FtFAEtSaQAAadDy.jpg

Nintendo is back again with their classic copyright shenanigans, and this time it's once again against YouTube content creators.
The modding community for Breath of the Wild has been a popular topic and a new way to play the game ever since the release of the original back in 2017, from some meandering but funny mods like adding Waluigi as a model for Link, to mods adding entirely new content in the form of fanmade DLC "Second Wind", the game is being kept very much alive and fresh even 6 years after its original release.

However, Nintendo seems to think otherwise, and they don't like it when people play the game in forms they don't force intend you to, so in their usual grasp and abuse of the copyright system, and taking advantage of YouTube's awful system to dealing with copyright stuff, they blocked several videos of YouTube content creators that dared to showcase any kind of mods regarding Breath of the Wild (and some that also showcased other games, like Pokemon Scarlet/Violet) in this past week. Some creators not only got their videos blocked, but they also started receiving copyright strikes on a handful of their videos, to which, for those unaware, accumulating 3 copyright strikes means the immediate termination of the entire YouTube channel, and having one's entire YT channel at risk is something of great concern.



This isn't the first time Nintendo does something like this, and most certainly (and sadly), this won't be the last time neither, as Nintendo is well known for their tyrannical use of the copyright system to bend their will, even when both modding and emulation are known to be completely legal as long as there's no direct piracy involved to run the games, and more so since the videos are of a transformative nature and fall under the legal "fair use" term.
These recent attacks from Nintendo to BotW modders seems to be related to the upcoming release of the BotW sequel, Tears of the Kingdom, releasing less than a month away in May 12th, so it seems to be a tactic of sorts to "protect" their IP brand from undesirable usage by them.

Some content creators, like PointCrow, have started to counter-claim these copyright claims by Nintendo, as stated directly through Twitter:
PointCrow said:
Update: I have appealed these claims. As of now, they are still visible for you to watch -- however, they are not monetized. Hopefully Nintendo releases these claims, as I significantly transform their work and my videos are under fair use.

While the counter-claim can liberate the videos to be watched, they can still be claimed yet again by Nintendo, but this time with a lawsuit in hand, so it remains to be seen if Nintendo will actually continue pursuing this rather abusive use of the copyright system in their favour.
 

MasterJ360

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,802
Trophies
1
Age
35
XP
3,458
Country
United States
Not surprising to be honest. I mean there used to be a lot of YT channels who only uploaded Nintendo exclusive games. Once Nintendo started dishing out copyright claims they pretty much ended them or they had to move to another platform to gain revenue streaming. Thats without any mods btw just basic gameplay advertising for them.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: StrayGuitarist

Tomato123

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2020
Messages
734
Trophies
1
Location
England
XP
2,518
Country
United Kingdom
I don't really understand. Posting gameplay footage is legal, isn't it?
Even under their own content guidelines, there was nothing wrong with the videos or mod. It doesn't mention anything wrong with modding, unless you count the line "only permitted to use Nintendo Game Content that has been officially released" which I think is intended to mean no leaking stuff.

The only other line which could be a problem is "We reserve the right to remove any content that we believe is unlawful, infringing, inappropriate, or not in line with these Guidelines." but it isn't unlawful or infringing as it's not pirating the game, using any of BOTW's source code or anything like that. And if multiplayer is inappropriate then Splatoon must be the wild west.
 

Deleted member 194275

Edson Arantes do Nascimento
Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2009
Messages
2,685
Trophies
2
XP
4,351
I don't really understand. Posting gameplay footage is legal, isn't it?
Not that I agree but Nintendo owns those assets. They allow gameplay videos as much and as long as they like.

Music industry dont tolerate you to use nothing at all, Nintendo can take this route if they like.
 

HRudyPlayZ

Developer, Gamer and Power User.
Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2016
Messages
371
Trophies
0
XP
2,062
Country
France
I don't really understand. Posting gameplay footage is legal, isn't it?
It's legal, but you assume Nintendo cares to respect the law, which isn't the case.
Anybody can fill a DMCA for whatever they want, even if it's not actually valid.
 
Last edited by HRudyPlayZ,

Bladexdsl

fanboys triggered 9k+
Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
21,150
Trophies
2
Location
Queensland
XP
12,248
Country
Australia
I don't really understand. Posting gameplay footage is legal, isn't it?
havn't you heard? according to all mighty nintendo law if they say it's illegal...than it really is! doesn't matter what THE REST OF THE WORLD thinks or what the law REALLY IS. what they so goes and fuck everyone else! :glare:
 
Last edited by Bladexdsl,

MikaDubbz

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2017
Messages
3,850
Trophies
1
Age
36
XP
7,313
Country
United States
Moves like this make me wonder if TotK has a multiplayer mode that they've yet to reveal (or perhaps intend to add later as DLC). Because I mean there are multiplayer mods of older Zelda games like Ocarina of Time or newer games like Mario Odyssey that Nintendo hasn't even bothered to strike down. I find it curious I guess.
 
Last edited by MikaDubbz,
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
1,288
Trophies
2
Age
31
Location
Arcadia
XP
3,712
Country
Italy
Honestly, I'm more surprised those assholes didn't do this the nanosecond this mod was unveiled.
Well, if you know what the Streisand effect is, you know retarted moves like these just only have the opposite effect of what those idiots at craptendo want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Henx

Noctosphere

Nova's Guardian
Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2013
Messages
6,756
Trophies
3
Age
30
Location
Biblically accurate Hell
XP
18,718
Country
Canada
I mean, AFAIK,
modding games is legal
modding console is legal
emulator is legal

The only way they'd have to legally take his videos down would be to prouve he is using an illegally obtained rom
Do they have any proof?
 

Kioku

猫。子猫です!
Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
12,008
Trophies
3
Location
In the Murderbox!
Website
www.twitch.tv
XP
16,149
Country
United States
I mean, AFAIK,
modding games is legal
modding console is legal
emulator is legal

The only way they'd have to legally take his videos down would be to prouve he is using an illegally obtained rom
Do they have any proof?
The content is borrowed, meaning we apparently have no legal right to share or record this content. Let alone modifying it to add or change mechanics. According to Nintendo anyway…
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum

General chit-chat
Help Users
  • BakerMan @ BakerMan:
    i said i was sleeping...
  • BakerMan @ BakerMan:
    sleeping with uremum
  • K3Nv2 @ K3Nv2:
    Even my mum slept on that uremum
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    yall im torn... ive been hacking away at tales of phantasia GBA (the USA version) and have so many documents of reverse engineering i've done
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    I just found out that the EU version is better in literally every way, better sound quality, better lighting, and there's even a patch someone made to make the text look nicer
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    Do I restart now using what i've learned on the EU version since it's a better overall experience? or do I continue with the US version since that is what ive been using, and if someone decides to play my hack, it would most likely be that version?
  • Sicklyboy @ Sicklyboy:
    @TwoSpikedHands, I'll preface this with the fact that I know nothing about the game, but, I think it depends on what your goals are. Are you trying to make a definitive version of the game? You may want to refocus your efforts on the EU version then. Or, are you trying to make a better US version? In which case, the only way to make a better US version is to keep on plugging away at that one ;)
  • Sicklyboy @ Sicklyboy:
    I'm not familiar with the technicalities of the differences between the two versions, but I'm wondering if at least some of those differences are things that you could port over to the US version in your patch without having to include copyrighted assets from the EU version
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    @Sicklyboy I am wanting to fully change the game and bend it to my will lol. I would like to eventually have the ability to add more characters, enemies, even have a completely different story if i wanted. I already have the ability to change the tilemaps in the US version, so I can basically make my own map and warp to it in game - so I'm pretty far into it!
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    I really would like to make a hack that I would enjoy playing, and maybe other people would too. swapping to the EU version would also mean my US friends could not legally play it
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    I am definitely considering porting over some of the EU features without using the actual ROM itself, tbh that would probably be the best way to go about it... but i'm sad that the voice acting is so.... not good on the US version. May not be a way around that though
  • TwoSpikedHands @ TwoSpikedHands:
    I appreciate the insight!
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    @TwoSpikedHands just switch, all the knowledge you learned still applies and most of the code and assets should be the same anyway
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    and realistically they wouldn't

    be able to play it legally anyway since they need a ROM and they probably don't have the means to dump it themselves
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    why the shit does the shitbox randomly insert newlines in my messages
  • Veho @ Veho:
    It does that when I edit a post.
  • Veho @ Veho:
    It inserts a newline in a random spot.
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    never had that i don't think
  • Karma177 @ Karma177:
    do y'all think having an sd card that has a write speed of 700kb/s is a bad idea?
    trying to restore emunand rn but it's taking ages... (also when I finished the first time hekate decided to delete all my fucking files :wacko:)
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    @Karma177 that sd card is 100% faulty so yes, its a bad idea
  • The Real Jdbye @ The Real Jdbye:
    even the slowest non-sdhc sd cards are a few MB/s
  • Karma177 @ Karma177:
    @The Real Jdbye it hasn't given me any error trying to write things on it so I don't really think it's faulty (pasted 40/50gb+ folders and no write errors)
  • DinohScene @ DinohScene:
    run h2testw on it
  • DinohScene @ DinohScene:
    when SD cards/microSD write speeds drop below a meg a sec, they're usually on the verge of dying
    DinohScene @ DinohScene: when SD cards/microSD write speeds drop below a meg a sec, they're usually on the verge of dying