Sealed copy of Pokemon Yellow graded A+ allegedly destroyed by US Customs

1674495120199.png

Stephen Kick, who runs under the username of @pripyatbeast, posted on Twitter an image of a received package after being handled by customs. The package was supposed to be an encased sealed copy of Pokemon Yellow, graded A+ with a score of 9.2 by Wata Games with an alleged worth of around $3'800 dollars, but instead, the owner got a broken acrylic case, with a mangled seal and sliced box of Pokemon Yellow.

The highest rated Pokemon Yellow game is also an A+, but with a score of 9.4, which is currently going up for around $10'500 dollars in price.
While the morality and legality of sealed copies of widely available games as Pokemon Yellow is highly questionable and up for debate, and regardless of its alleged worth, it's always heartbreaking to see something you ordering getting destroyed in shipping or customs.

 

AmandaRose

Do what I do. Hold tight and pretend it’s a plan
Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2015
Messages
10,199
Trophies
1
Location
Glasgow
Website
www.rockstarnorth.com
XP
16,195
Country
United Kingdom
I don't believe any of this supposed story. For me the dude is trying an insurance scam and he received his Pokemon Yellow in perfect condition then destroyed another Pokemon Yellow box to claim on the insurance and recoup his massive outlay.
 

Foxi4

Endless Trash
Global Moderator
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
30,829
Trophies
3
Location
Gaming Grotto
XP
29,869
Country
Poland
I agree but I think the point is exactly to speculate on it, not to preserve it necessarily. Rather the value their preserving is the OG unboxing experience. It isn't a preatical thing to preserve but since it can only be done once, it values up.

That said, did GBA Gameboy games even had a seal? I don't think I ever bought a GBA Gameboy game with a seal.
You’re not wrong - video game collecting has become big business, and “mint” copies (based on an arbitrary scale for the most part) are treated like investments - we’ve been through this many times, like with Ty plushies and other assorted nonsense. I still remember a time people were outraged that they’d have to pay $500 for a copy of Radiant Silvergun, and that was genuinely a rare piece of software, so there was actual scarcity involved. Pokémon isn’t a particularly rare piece - you can’t throw a rock and not hit some kind of Pokémon game. The n-thousand dollar premium on what amounts to cellophane and cardboard is inexcusable, and everybody knows those prices are artificially inflated by grading houses. Heck, those graders often aren’t even subject matter experts anyway. Earlier this month they admitted that they gave a “perfect” score to a reproduction cartridge and had to profusely apologise because they “didn’t know” those exist.

Edit: Here’s their pathetic statement. They can’t even tell if the damn game is real, how can they *possibly* be able to grade it on any scale? Scammers pretending they’re king shit, nothing more, nothing less.

6E422881-56A5-4879-8CAA-72FFB769A1ED.jpeg

Maybe this is a controversial point of view, but I’m a collector *and* a gamer. I honestly believe that those products were meant to be played, not to be put into a plexiglass box never to be touched again. Collectors who do that care more about appearances than what they’re actually collecting - yes, take care of the collection by all means, but if you’re never going to play any of it, it has no value to me.
 

r1vver

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2017
Messages
551
Trophies
0
XP
979
Country
Russia
Why was this game so poorly packaged? :O
I mean, some people mail all kinds of cognacs in crystal bottles, etc. and it's okay, as long as the packaging is good...
 
  • Like
Reactions: SylverReZ

The Catboy

GBAtemp Official Catboy™: Boywife
Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
28,012
Trophies
4
Location
Making a non-binary fuss
XP
39,597
Country
Antarctica
In all fairness, the entire grading system is a scam. There is no additional value in having a sealed copy of anything. In fact, in the case of many products it is *detrimental* from a preservationist standpoint (built-in batteries, capacitor plague-era products, suicide PCB’s and so on).
Ok but they still destroyed his property
 

Foxi4

Endless Trash
Global Moderator
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
30,829
Trophies
3
Location
Gaming Grotto
XP
29,869
Country
Poland
Ok but they still destroyed his property
Customs far and wide reserve the right to open any packaging in order to inspect its contents - this is done both when something suspicious is detected *and* at random. The product is not considered “destroyed” as it is fully functional. It’s the collector’s community that places undue value to cardboard, the average consumer wouldn’t give two shits about this, and neither do customs. Unless the package included specific instructions that this is a collectible and the whole point is that it’s sealed, they’re not liable, and I’d argue that even if there was such a note, they’re not obligated to care.
 

Foxi4

Endless Trash
Global Moderator
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
30,829
Trophies
3
Location
Gaming Grotto
XP
29,869
Country
Poland
Now that you mention it, I don't think they did...
I would have to pull out some of my old packaging (yes, I still own packaging for my games, neatly folded and filed), but if I recall correctly the boxes were shrink wrapped, there was no sticker seal on mine as there was no need for it.
They did, it was pretty cheap film-like plastic, but they came sealed.
Yeah, shrink wrap. I think they meant a plastic sticker seal on the flap, which I don’t think Nintendo used.
 
Last edited by Foxi4,
  • Like
Reactions: Osakasan and Kioku

Ferris1000

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
251
Trophies
0
Age
33
Location
Titan
XP
2,386
Country
Germany
I would say AWSOME...I hope the Customs do that with all WATA Packages.
Those who are that dumb and use the Scam company WATA doesn't deserve any better.

Grading and Grading Scams destroys the Retro Collector Market.
BTW: WATA Graded a Bootleg Copy of a Game not so long ago, no wonder why the Customs are suspicious
 

Adran_Marit

Walküre's Hacker
Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2015
Messages
3,781
Trophies
1
Location
42*South
XP
4,562
Country
Australia
You’re not wrong - video game collecting has become big business, and “mint” copies (based on an arbitrary scale for the most part) are treated like investments - we’ve been through this many times, like with Ty plushies and other assorted nonsense. I still remember a time people were outraged that they’d have to pay $500 for a copy of Radiant Silvergun, and that was genuinely a rare piece of software, so there was actual scarcity involved. Pokémon isn’t a particularly rare piece - you can’t throw a rock and not hit some kind of Pokémon game. The n-thousand dollar premium on what amounts to cellophane and cardboard is inexcusable, and everybody knows those prices are artificially inflated by grading houses. Heck, those graders often aren’t even subject matter experts anyway. Earlier this month they admitted that they gave a “perfect” score to a reproduction cartridge and had to profusely apologise because they “didn’t know” those exist.

Edit: Here’s their pathetic statement. They can’t even tell if the damn game is real, how can they *possibly* be able to grade it on any scale? Scammers pretending they’re king shit, nothing more, nothing less.

View attachment 348948

Maybe this is a controversial point of view, but I’m a collector *and* a gamer. I honestly believe that those products were meant to be played, not to be put into a plexiglass box never to be touched again. Collectors who do that care more about appearances than what they’re actually collecting - yes, take care of the collection by all means, but if you’re never going to play any of it, it has no value to me.
How does a grading company not know reproductions exist? spoiler they would knoe exaftly what they are doing hence adding yo the scam more
 

pustal

Yeah! This is happenin'!
Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2011
Messages
1,562
Trophies
2
Location
Emerald Coast
Website
web.archive.org
XP
6,269
Country
Portugal
You’re not wrong - video game collecting has become big business, and “mint” copies (based on an arbitrary scale for the most part) are treated like investments - we’ve been through this many times, like with Ty plushies and other assorted nonsense. I still remember a time people were outraged that they’d have to pay $500 for a copy of Radiant Silvergun, and that was genuinely a rare piece of software, so there was actual scarcity involved. Pokémon isn’t a particularly rare piece - you can’t throw a rock and not hit some kind of Pokémon game. The n-thousand dollar premium on what amounts to cellophane and cardboard is inexcusable, and everybody knows those prices are artificially inflated by grading houses. Heck, those graders often aren’t even subject matter experts anyway. Earlier this month they admitted that they gave a “perfect” score to a reproduction cartridge and had to profusely apologise because they “didn’t know” those exist.

Edit: Here’s their pathetic statement. They can’t even tell if the damn game is real, how can they *possibly* be able to grade it on any scale? Scammers pretending they’re king shit, nothing more, nothing less.

View attachment 348948

Maybe this is a controversial point of view, but I’m a collector *and* a gamer. I honestly believe that those products were meant to be played, not to be put into a plexiglass box never to be touched again. Collectors who do that care more about appearances than what they’re actually collecting - yes, take care of the collection by all means, but if you’re never going to play any of it, it has no value to me.
Let's start our own grading system, based on cartridge/disc preservation state and based evaluation and make tons of money. Also with blackjack and hookers.
 

SDA

Wanderin' Jelly Boy
Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2020
Messages
684
Trophies
0
Age
19
Location
Parete, Italy
XP
2,265
Country
Italy
I believe those customs do not like Pokémon at all. Only real Pokémon haters would be crazy enough to destroy the physical cartridge to pieces!
 

1B51004

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2020
Messages
413
Trophies
1
XP
2,200
Country
United States
ooh, that's painful. something you own that is supposedly worth a lot of money gets recked by improper handling/ U.S. customs.

Does it happen often? Haven't really heard much about US customs destroying games until... now actually.
 

Adran_Marit

Walküre's Hacker
Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2015
Messages
3,781
Trophies
1
Location
42*South
XP
4,562
Country
Australia
ooh, that's painful. something you own that is supposedly worth a lot of money gets recked by improper handling/ U.S. customs.

Does it happen often? Haven't really heard much about US customs destroying games until... now actually.
It was graded by WATA games, which has been exposed as a scam company trying to raise the prices of retro video games, so who cares
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum

General chit-chat
Help Users
    BigOnYa @ BigOnYa: After watching, that I feel like I'm on them already