heartgold said:
As long as it's comfortable, who cares how it looks like. My 3DS hardly leaves the house anyway.
This is how I feel. It's easy to criticize the bulky design, especially the aesthetics of it, but it could really enhance the gaming experience. I was hoping for a second analog since before the 3DS design was revealed. I don't like using the touch screen for aiming because it's uncomfortable for me to hold and play, although the accuracy is spot-on. I also like the added shoulder buttons, and it reminds me of how Nintendo improved the Classic Controller for the Wii. If there is a battery in that 2 inches of plastic, this could be even better.
The biggest downfall for me, is that I like using crystal/shell style cases to reinforce the loose hinges on my system. Using this add-on will obviously make those cases useless, unless somebody just wants to protect the upper half of the 3DS. I only play my 3DS at home, so I have no problem with it. For those out in public, like on the bus or train, this thing could draw some attention (in a "WTF is that" kind of way).