The NEXT sig Competition

[JeX-]

well we know what happened to the other thread.

i'm just going to continue as if it never happened, thats the best way.

If you did'nt gt what i said here it is again.

Hi ya all,

I was thinking, since the the other sig competition we had, we could launch another one.

To encourage more people in entering and taking part, we could have some sort of badge for the winner, like there is for a Admin, and super mod and the news paper for us magazine staff. The winner could have some sort of icon to wear until the next sig competition, and if s/he loses the winner of that competition gets it. There could be a Sig competition every two months or something, so it gives people time to improve their skills and the winner to wear its medal.

If you agree i'll search for some good icons, and other people can also make them if they wish to and then post them here.

so what do you guys think?....think its a good Idea?

 

[neocat]

How do you know?
Do ppl need to have your taste to be good judges?
Sometimes you make some really lame statements

 

[D2_]

o i dont know, maybe because i dont see the words "sig making forum" anywhere around here.

 

[torN]

Now now boys

If you want I could get a proper judge who knows what he's doing.

 

[JeX-]

How do you know?
Do ppl need to have your taste to be good judges?
Sometimes you make some really lame statements

Who are you talking to?

quote the members speech so other people know who your talking to....

I think D2 is right. Say if one entry took alot of hard time and effort and it showed, and the judge (being an exspert, an' all) would know how difficult it was to pull off....but someone with out that knowledge would not know that, there for over seeing that aspect.

A or Some judges would be better, if we dont get any then it may have to come to the poll idea, unless someone else has some sort of other idea.

-T J

 

[Tempest Stormwin]

Most of the people who post here are left-brained logic nuts (I put myself in this category as well), and as such would have trouble judging. I'd like to, but I doubt I could spot half of the subtleties and nifty artistic effects over the holistic impression. If you can think of any of our artists who're NOT in this competition already, then ask them.

One solution, though -- have the competers judge each other. There looks to be over five of you here, so this will work. Let each person assign a score from 1-10 to each sig. The highest and lowest individual scores will be removed, and the others added up to provide a point scale. Polls will be used to clear up ties. You'll need to assign an adjucator, though -- a neutral guy to do the totalling, a guy you'd PM the scores to and he'd do the math.

What do you think?

-Tempest out.-

 

[dice]

Can I be a judge ???

Dice runs for his life

 

[D2_]

how about this? we all sign up in a sig making forum i know. make a thread called "gbatemp competition". than the ppl there can judge. just dont go crying to me if they dont go easy on ur sigs.

 

[|{urt}{ecti]

Well - i think i will participate, too - But i don't have much time for it during the week (I have to work).

Another thing is, that we need rules for this like:
"you are only allowed to post one sig a day"
or
"height and weight must be at least...or maximum..."
etc.

anyone who agree with me?

 

[torN]

Yea D2, lets do it at taggerz, they wont go easy on us though

But criticism is good.

 

[JeX-]

Most of the people who post here are left-brained logic nuts (I put myself in this category as well), and as such would have trouble judging. I'd like to, but I doubt I could spot half of the subtleties and nifty artistic effects over the holistic impression. If you can think of any of our artists who're NOT in this competition already, then ask them.

One solution, though -- have the competers judge each other. There looks to be over five of you here, so this will work. Let each person assign a score from 1-10 to each sig. The highest and lowest individual scores will be removed, and the others added up to provide a point scale. Polls will be used to clear up ties. You'll need to assign an adjucator, though -- a neutral guy to do the totalling, a guy you'd PM the scores to and he'd do the math.

What do you think?

-Tempest out.-

If we then judge each other, then anyone of us could de-grade the other person.....just like King02 & Inuyasha...Do you think King02 would judge inuyasha's sig truthfuly? **loughs uncontrollably**

any way you get my point.

-T J

 

[torN]

If we then judge each other, then anyone of us could de-grade the other person.....just like King02 & Inuyasha...Do you think King02 would judge inuyasha's sig truthfuly? Â**loughs uncontrollably**

any way you get my point.

-T J

LMFAO. Well if he stopped copying me then maybe.

 

[dice]

how about this? we all sign up in a sig making forum i know. make a thread called "gbatemp competition". than the ppl there can judge. just dont go crying to me if they dont go easy on ur sigs.

Well whats the web page ???

 

[torN]

We'll give it out when everyone has agreed to doing it.

 

[D2_]

http://www.taggerz.com/forums

im making the thread in the challenge forum now

 

[torN]

Contest Thread

 

[Tempest Stormwin]

Most of the people who post here are left-brained logic nuts (I put myself in this category as well), and as such would have trouble judging. ÂI'd like to, but I doubt I could spot half of the subtleties and nifty artistic effects over the holistic impression. ÂIf you can think of any of our artists who're NOT in this competition already, then ask them.

One solution, though -- have the competers judge each other. ÂThere looks to be over five of you here, so this will work. Let each person assign a score from 1-10 to each sig. The highest and lowest individual scores will be removed, and the others added up to provide a point scale. Polls will be used to clear up ties. ÂYou'll need to assign an adjucator, though -- a neutral guy to do the totalling, a guy you'd PM the scores to and he'd do the math.

What do you think?

-Tempest out.-

If we then judge each other, then anyone of us could de-grade the other person.....just like King02 & Inuyasha...Do you think King02 would judge inuyasha's sig truthfuly? **loughs uncontrollably**

any way you get my point.

-T J

I see you found a better solution. Good luck, everyone.

TJ, that's why I said the lowest and highest would be cut out, to account for self-awarded 10s and insults like that one. However, the sig forum is a better idea.

-Tempest out.-

 

[ruffmeister]

well i didnt make the sig but ill enter mine here and give my prize to the geeza who made mine

 

[dice]

Yeah same here

 

[Zarcon]

lol, so the judges will be the tagger people? ok, this'll be funny

 

[torN]

Not funny, but they'll go extremely hard on you. But so far my work has gotten 7-8's from some of teh best taggerz

*Edit*

Hehe when you see this Inu, I'd like to see you copy this